by Freddy J. Nager, Founder of Atomic Tango + Occasional Coupon Clipper
Just read a Mashable article by daily-deal entrepreneur John Amato, who trumpets how great Groupon and other discountosaurs are for everyone (“Why Daily Deals Are Here To Stay”).
His key points: people have always loved discounts, the customer acquisition costs are relatively low compared to other methods, and the market is still maturing. He’s right on the first point, needs to provide more data for the second, and is completely off point with the third. (The market is still maturing? What’s that got to do with whether a tactic is worth employing? And isn’t that an argument to hold off until the market’s ripe?)
My thoughts: While there are certainly some businesses that benefit from offering deals, let’s not apply this tactic too broadly…
First of all, discounting devalues the product.
If you have a luxury or prestige brand, you will destroy its hard-won position with overzealous deals. Also, any kind of discounting, whether a coupon or a clearance sale, teaches consumers that they shouldn’t pay full retail, and they should simply hold off until the next sale. As advertising legend David Ogilvy once noted, discounts are addictive. Give them once to a consumer, and the consumer will want them again and again.
The second problem is that this kind of daily deal is not discriminatory enough.
A company should make special offers to the kinds of customers and the kinds of behaviors it wants. It’s a waste to offer a money-losing deal to a short-term bargain hunter who has no brand loyalty and will not return. It’s also a waste to offer a massive discount to a regular customer who was going to pay regular price anyway. A more strategic approach would be to offer special loyalty rewards to current customers, and special long-term incentives to prospective customers. And those rewards and incentives don’t have to be discounts.
There are other issues with daily deals…
Retail staff and inventory managers may be unprepared to handle rushes, and consumers are already suffering from daily deal fatigue. (I’ve personally unsubscribed from the onslaught of discount emails that were little distinguished from spam. Really, how many tanning offers do I need?)
So while daily deals offer some benefits, such as a performance-based advertising platform, they’re definitely not a good deal for everyone.
Update 7/17/13: Amato was clearly so wrong in his post that it’s no longer here to stay.